IC Markets vs AvaTrade: Which Is Better in 2026?

We tested both. Here's the honest verdict.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Data accurate as of Q1 2026. Verify current terms with each broker directly.

Key Differences

IC Markets is regulated by ASIC (Australia), CySEC (Cyprus), FSA (Seychelles). This places it in the Tier-1 Regulated category — the highest standard of retail investor protection, with mandatory client fund segregation, negative balance protection, and access to compensation schemes where applicable.

AvaTrade holds licences from Central Bank of Ireland, ASIC (Australia), CySEC (Cyprus), FSCA (South Africa), FSA (Japan), ADGM (Abu Dhabi), making it Tier-1 Regulated. With 6 Tier-1 regulators, AvaTrade meets the highest standards of retail broker oversight.

Both brokers operate under comparable Tier-1 Regulated frameworks — a tie on regulatory safety. The practical difference comes down to jurisdiction: choose the entity that operates under your country's local regulator for maximum protection.

Trading costs are where many brokers win or lose active traders. On a standard EUR/USD 1-lot trade ($100,000 notional), the all-in cost breaks down as follows: IC Markets charges a spread of 0.0 pips avg (Raw ECN) (approximately $0) plus $7/lot round turn (MT5) commission — totalling roughly $7 per lot round turn.

AvaTrade runs 0.9 pips (fixed, no commission) spread with $0 (spread-only) — an all-in cost of approximately $9 per lot. Over 100 lots per month, the difference adds up to roughly $200 in favour of IC Markets.

IC Markets wins on trading costs. IC Markets's 0.0 pips avg (Raw ECN) structure and $7/lot round turn (MT5) make it the more cost-efficient choice for active traders — particularly those trading multiple lots daily. AvaTrade's pricing suits traders who value predictability over rock-bottom spreads.

IC Markets supports MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader. This multi-platform approach gives traders genuine flexibility — from algorithmic trading on MT5 to discretionary charting on MetaTrader 4.

AvaTrade offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, AvaTradeGO, AvaOptions, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade. Its proprietary platform is purpose-built for its instrument range and is often more intuitive for clients new to CFD trading.

For beginners: AvaTrade wins — its platform is more approachable. For active traders: IC Markets has the edge with the broadest toolset. For algo traders: IC Markets is better placed, offering cTrader's native algo environment alongside MT5. Overall platform winner: AvaTrade (6 platforms vs 3).

Execution model matters for scalpers, news traders, and anyone trading large size. IC Markets operates as a ECN (Electronic Communications Network) broker — routing orders directly to liquidity providers with no dealing desk intervention, which means tighter spreads during normal conditions and no re-quotes.

AvaTrade runs a Market Maker / spread-only model. The spread-only model means all costs are baked in, making it straightforward to calculate trade profitability without tracking per-lot commission. On speed and slippage: AvaTrade reports execution in sub-50ms for standard orders, with no restrictions on scalping or EA use (note: this broker uses a dealing-desk model, which may introduce restrictions during volatile conditions).

Execution winner: IC Markets — scoring 10/10 versus AvaTrade's 7/10. IC Markets's ECN (Electronic Communications Network) model is better suited to active traders. AvaTrade's execution remains adequate for retail strategies but is not optimised for professional-level frequency or volume.

Getting started matters. IC Markets requires a minimum deposit of $200. The $200 minimum is moderate — accessible to most retail traders but a meaningful commitment for beginners.

AvaTrade starts at $100. $100 is a low barrier, making AvaTrade accessible to traders building up from smaller bankrolls. Account opening is typically completed online in under 24 hours for both brokers.

On accessibility: AvaTrade wins — $100 to start vs $200. If capital efficiency matters, AvaTrade lets you begin trading with less at risk.

Who Should Choose Which?

Read full reviews

Compare more brokers

Open Your NextTrade Account in 3 Minutes

Raw ECN spreads from 0.0 pips. $50 minimum deposit. MT5 platform. No dealing desk.

You'll be redirected to dashboard.nexttrade.com · Affiliate link · CFD trading involves risk